The plot is simple. The setting happens three hundred years after this event called “The Fall”, leaving us in the 26th century where there a floating city and everyone lives below it in poverty. It’s pretty much following the dots to making a sci-fi story set in the future and since we are following the dots, there is also the cyborg cliche and they are the main gimmick of the series. Our protagonist is found pretty much limbless in a dump by a Dr Ido AKA the surrogate father figure who patches her up with robotic limbs and upon finding out that she has amnesia, names her Alita and treats her like a replacement daughter. From there, she becomes a “hunter-warrior” which is effectively a bounty hunter, finds out more about her past and gains and loses a romantic interest over the course of the movie before ending in a cliffhanger. It’s pretty much a dot to dot mainstream sci fi action movie with nothing interesting going on and while the plot is pretty much the same as the original source, I feel like it’s worsened by everything else. Now, a rather stale plot can be somewhat forgiven if everything else is good about it and that’s probably why the Battle Angel series is still going but the way this movie was made, it’s not going to be easy to make this redeemable.
To start with the complaints so early, I wanna talk about the CGI, specifically what the hell is with Alita’s design. It’s so horrendous and people had to look at that and think that was ok. Like, why does she have such large eyes? Was it the decision of some out of touch Hollywood executives thinking that giving this character large eyes to represent the usual sizes found in anime/manga would make her more likeable but if they were going for that angle, that just brings up so many other questions. For example, why does Alita only have these large freakish eyes while everyone else have normal eyes. Like even the other cyborgs have normal eyes so why is Alita the odd one out? And while we are talking about CGI, the rest of it isn’t horrendous but it feels like most of it is unnecessary. To be honest, I should’ve known that this movie would consist of 90% CGI when David Cameron has his name slapped all over this product. Yeah, he only got a screenplay credit but considering the over use of CGI and the fact they were advertising the movie as “From The Creator Of Avatar”, it’s obviously that this is David’s brainchild. Now the CGI is good for like two action scenes and that’s it because we are at that point where CGI looks so realistic, it looks fake so in other words, we have done a full circle when it comes to crap looking CGI. I feel like they could’ve and should’ve used practical effects when they could for example, Alita. If they did that with practical effects, it would’ve been much better and not horrible with those creepy anime eyes. I’m sorry, I can’t get past the creepy anime eyes that Alita has like how I can’t get past the acting quality. Wow, what a great transition on my behalf but I needed to get to it because most of it is on same level of trash that you would find at Manila's dumpsite.
Because most of these actors have to interact with CGI, effectively someone in a stupid green suit or morph-suit and there is no way in hell that these actors could act seriously without feeling awkward and you could tell that in the acting quality. Alita herself felt extremely stilted because again, trying to do your job to your full potential while looking like a bumpy dildo is hard, especially when you are already bad at acting without the stupid suit. It takes a serious actor who has experience with motion capturing and doesn’t let themselves feel stupid while wearing such a contraption do to do motion capturing in a live action movie. But even if you somehow hire the female version of Andy Serkis, all these other actors still end up acting like dead fish because if the previous complaint. But let’s do the usual excuse that most of the cinema going audience would say to people to critics and just “switch off my brain” and “try to enjoy the movie” which I tried to do on my second viewing but I still couldn’t get past the CGI on top of numerous things. For example, the lover interest aspect is stupid but I think that just comes down to the actor. I don’t know why I hate him so much but maybe it’s because he is the lover interest of Alita, which makes him a weird robot lover which kinda weirds me out or maybe it’s the actor is just horrible. It could be the CGI again but I feel like even when he is talking to other “humans”, he is still forcing it. I swear some B-list actor could’ve done a better job then this D-grade hack. I got nothing much else to mention now since this movie is just that bland and uninsulting when viewed from the point of a non anime fan and I already talked about how I felt about it as an anime fan so I guess it’s time to talk about how I feel about it from a writer’s view.
This is going to be my biggest problem with the movie and it’s the quality of the script or rather, the adaption quality. For me, there is two kinds of adaptations: there is the lazy adaption where they rip out the original plot and just paste that into a word document E.G the unimaginative “Romeo + Juliet” and then there is the adaption that takes advantage of the new media format and/or newer technology to tell the story in a new and interesting way E.G uhhhh… Ok, so I don’t have an example for that but that’s because I haven’t been able to find one yet. My point that I’m trying to make is that this movie is the former since they pretty much just ripped out everything from the manga series and slapped it onto the screen with little thought. I feel like they could’ve taken their time and work on updating the script to not have only better dialogue but better character building moments but they didn’t do that. This movie has been apparently in the works since the 2000s so they had probably at least had a decade to update on the script so it felt like an improvement of the original story but they didn’t. This is also coming from mister “I have a screenplay credit” David Cameron who worked on Avatar, the supposedly “ground breaking” movie which is really good (which I still don’t get since the movie looks like dumb CGI crap with a pretentious plot) so for such a good director, he was so reeling it in here even if he was just working on the story side of things which I refuse to believe with all this CGI. Let’s say if he was just working on the story aspect, well I guess this makes him a hack writer since he just ripped everything from the original story line. If they actually put effort in making this stale and old plot more likeable and interesting, this movie would’ve been better, shoddy acting included but they didn’t and that’s one of the things that bring down the movie.
I don’t know who is at here to blame? Is it the long production hell this movie went through since as I mention, this movie as been in the works since the 2000s. Maybe it’s David Cameron being a hack writer and not taking the liberty he had and used it to improve the original plot or maybe it’s Hollywood’s need to cash in everything because it’s now an industry where most of the money is made from remakes and nostalgia. I certainly can’t be the only one who has noticed that Hollywood has been trying to cash in on every single idea and concept they can now. From Disney’s so called “Live action remakes” to studios rushing out cinematic universes to compete with Marvel, it seems like they are exhausting every single thing possible to the point they are resorting to nicking ideas from their Asian neighbours. It feels like within the triple A mainstream movie scene, we are seeing a slow decline in original movies. Luckily, the industry is still full with innovative directors so we haven’t lost all hope yet but eventually, it’s probably going to end up like that.
When I was discussing why I hated this movie with someone who liked the movie, I was told to chill off from hating on the CGI and that prompted me to go watch the movie a second time with a different perspective; the perspective of a casual movie goer. I only lasted ten minutes because for me, the CGI is just not good. I just can’t see myself enjoying this movie while with a Marvel movie, I can see myself going back and watching those because while I hate them from my usual perspective, I can still enjoy some of the movies because it’s still fun if I just “switch off”. Alita gets a 3/10 from me and I have no regrets saying so.
I guess this is the part where I apologise for disappearing for another couple months. Between this and the last review, it has just been a mess for me from my PC being unable to run my editing software anymore meaning I can’t make my YouTube videos for a while so I been sorting out my new PC in the background. I started tafe so I have to spend a lot more time on doing my homework and not writing while I do have the backlog, I honestly wasn’t happy with what I wrote back then so I ended up just deleting them. Don’t worry, I’m back now and I will try to be consistent again since I have finally balanced out my work/relax balance and in fact, the next two reviews are going to be on movies so tune in for next week where I talk about “Captain Marvel”. That’s going to be a fun shitshow.